Discussion in 'Movies, Entertainment & Various Music Genres' started by Konscious, Aug 5, 2008.
heath ledger has my vote
I still think Jack was the best.
they played the part much differently
Heath protrayed the Joker correctly in the way that the Joker was suppose to be...Jack did well but not on his level
Why isn't this thread closed?
I already replied with my answer.
I was in a bar the other day and I overheard this young lady speaking on the Joker portrayals and she said that Jack was the best... maybe it's a nostalgia thing, because she looked to be around my age... most of you were probably too young to appreciate great acting when that movie came out.
You're fuckin nutz! Jack showed heath how to do it man. Jack made joker crazy! If it wasn't for Jack, Heath would've never done what he did.
Posted via Mobile Device
The Joker was more then just a crazy villain..Jack may have showed him the way to be crazy but Heath played the Joker the way he was suppose to be played
I like them both, they all are great actors, how can we campare them
Dang, you guys spoke the truth on this one. Hard to add much more beyond.
Both performances were solid, each character fitting perfectly into the director's vision. Still, for me, the new joker just creeped me out beyond all belief and fit my vision of what he would be perfectly. Heath Ledger did that role right.
This thread is old as hell.
Anyway, Jack's Joker was fucking garbage. Some of you say you haven't seen the old one in a while, I have, garbage.
Hands down, Heath...
I only watch this movie over and over agin just to watch him work...
He slipped into the role and character seemlessly... Its a shame he cant come back for the Next one...
You think Jack would've known how to act as he did without the Comics?
Come on now... I used to watch the Original Batman once a day when I was a kid... Loved Jack as the Joker... But its a new Day and age... Ledger killed this role and hit it dead on...
It wasn't garbage, but it was just Jack playing Jack with more theatrics.
Heath was just more modern.... He embodied all the insane characteristics of what I believe the Joker would have... And played it to a "T"...
I hate Jack Nicholson! Heath is better I think...
i liked heaths ..and i was a kid when the 1989 one came out..i loved jack in it but heaths darker joker just appealed more to me.
Separate names with a comma.